Tom Williams/Getty Images
- Divisions between progressive and moderate Democrats have boiled over following unexpected House losses and President-elect Joe Biden’s win in the presidential race.
- The public fight over congressional losses is just the first of what will likely be several flash points for Democrats in the coming months.
- Democratic operatives across the ideological spectrum told Business Insider that the truce progressives reached with more moderate Democrats to unify behind Biden’s candidacy is over.
- Visit Business Insider’s homepage for more stories.
President-elect Joe Biden hadn’t yet won the election when Democratic Party divisions spilled into public view.
During a House caucus call on Thursday, centrist Democrats lashed out at their progressive colleagues, arguing that calls for democratic socialism and defunding law enforcement were to blame for the party’s shocking loss of at least half a dozen swing district House members this cycle.
“We need to not ever use the word ‘socialist’ or ‘socialism’ ever again … We lost good members because of that,” Rep. Abigail Spanberger, a Virginia Democrat who prevailed in a tough reelection race, said on the call. “If we are classifying Tuesday as a success … we will get f—ing torn apart in 2022.”
After the call was leaked to the press, Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez took to Twitter and the media to accuse her more conservative colleagues of “finger pointing” and failing to take responsibility for their own strategic shortcomings.
“It’s irresponsible to pour gasoline on these already very delicate tensions in the party,” Ocasio-Cortez told CNN on Sunday. She told The New York Times in a Saturday interview that some vulnerable Democrats’ underinvestment in Facebook ads and other digital efforts was “criminal” and “malpractice.”
Read more: 30 top progressives ready to cajole the incoming Biden administration from its left flank
A few more moderate Democrats, including Rep. Conor Lamb, who won a competitive reelection race in Western Pennsylvania, and Majority Whip James Clyburn of South Carolina, went to the press to push back on Ocasio-Cortez.
Democratic operatives across the ideological spectrum told Business Insider that the truce progressives reached with moderate Democrats to unify behind Biden's candidacy last spring has expired. They expect progressives and centrists will continue to butt heads in coming battles over the House speakership, leadership of the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee (DCCC), Biden's cabinet, and legislative priorities in the new year.
Democratic flashpoints on the horizon
Some on the left argue that establishment and moderate Democrats should be taking cues from the left and, like Ocasio-Cortez is advocating, take advantage of the messaging skills they've honed.
Rebecca Katz, a progressive operative and former adviser to New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio, argued that centrist Democrats failed to deliver anything besides an anti-Trump message. She said the party needs a stronger proactive message on the economy and bringing down healthcare costs.
"You can't blame moderate losses on the left, that's just ridiculous," Katz told Business Insider. "When their incumbents went down in Democratic primaries, they never thought what is the left doing that we're not."
Ian Russell, a former deputy executive director of the DCCC, argued that Democratic losses can likely be chalked up both to damaging GOP attacks on left-wing talking points and on various tactical shortcomings. He called for an honest postmortem, but noted it's impossible to diagnose the problems without the relevant data.
"It's not going to be pleasant but we need to hold ourselves accountable and we need to be clear-eyed and cold-blooded in our analysis," Russell told Business Insider.
Rep. Cheri Bustos announced on Monday that she would step down as head of the DCCC following the party's poor showing last week. Coming battles over leadership of the DCCC and discussions over whether House Speaker Nancy Pelosi should serve another term will likely further divide progressives and moderates.
Basil Smikle, a Democratic political consultant and former executive director of the New York State Democratic Party, predicts that Democrats first "big test" of intra-party relations will come with the stimulus negotiations. Pelosi and Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell have already resumed talks over a desperately-needed economic relief bill and Democrats will be forced to compromise in order to pass it during the post-election lame-duck period.
Senate Republicans are even less willing than the Trump administration was to sign off on a multi-trillion dollar relief package.
"It's not likely that Democrats are going to get a lot of what they want," Smikle said. "I would imagine this is a moment that progressives are going to ask for a lot -- it's not unwarranted ... but perhaps the Speaker and Biden himself, who has articulated that he's going to work across the aisle, may not feel it's the time for it."
There's a general consensus that the party will be forced to reunite in 2021 to maintain its majority in the midterms. But left-wing voices outside of Washington are urging progressives to be loud in their opposition to moderate Democrats' demands on all fronts.
"I hope the truce, to the extent there was one, is over and I hope we start firing on all cylinders and firing shots across the bow," Corbin Trent, Ocasio-Cortez's former press secretary, told Business Insider. "The centrist Dem[ocrats] are as much our enemy … they brought us Trump, they'll deliver us Tom Cotton."